Am I Surrendering to Be Loved… or Because I Already Am?

I don’t offer myself to gain approval—I open my hands because I already have everything in Christ.

A Grace-Centered Conversation on the Heart Behind Surrender

“We love because He first loved us.” – 1 John 4:19
“I urge you, brothers and sisters, in view of God’s mercy, to offer your bodies as a living sacrifice…” – Romans 12:1

A Conversation After a Worship Night

Taylor:
Man… that song about surrender really got to me. “I give You my heart, I give You my soul…” I kept thinking, “Lord, take everything. I don’t want to hold anything back anymore.” But then I realized… I’ve prayed that before. Many times. And I keep messing it up. Maybe I haven’t surrendered enough.

Me:
Oh, I know that feeling. I used to rededicate my life to Jesus every time there was a powerful song or a convicting sermon. I'd walk away thinking, This time I really mean it. But deep down, I was hoping that my act of surrender would somehow make God more pleased with me.

Taylor’s View: The More I Surrender, the Closer God Will Be

Taylor looks down at her Bible. “But isn’t surrender a good thing? Doesn’t God want all of me? Jesus said in Luke 14:33, ‘Anyone who does not give up everything… cannot be My disciple.’ And Romans 12:1 calls us to be living sacrifices. Isn’t giving ourselves to God the way we show Him we’re serious?”

She flips through a few more:

• James 4:7 – “Submit yourselves, then, to God…”

• Matthew 16:24 – “Deny yourself, take up your cross, and follow Me.”

• Psalm 51:17 – “A broken and contrite heart, O God, you will not despise.”

Taylor looks up. “I just don’t want to be half-in, half-out. I want to surrender fully so He’ll really be with me.”

My Response: You Already Have What You’re Trying to Earn

I reach over and smile gently. “I hear you. But what if your surrender isn’t something you do to get closer to God—what if it’s your response to already being as close as possible in Christ?”

Taylor tilts her head. “You mean… I’m not surrendering for something?”

“Exactly. Romans 12:1 says, ‘In view of God’s mercy, offer your body as a living sacrifice.’ Not to get mercy—but because you already have it. The Cross proved you’re fully loved, fully accepted, fully His. Your surrender isn’t a purchase—it’s a response.”

I add, “You don’t die to earn His favor—you die because you’ve already been united with Christ in His death and resurrection (Rom. 6:5-6). That changes the entire tone of surrender.”

The Core Shift: Surrendering to Be vs. Surrendering Because You Are

Trying to surrender for acceptance says: If I give God more of me, maybe He’ll finally give me more of Him.
But surrendering from rest says: Because I have all of Him, I gladly give Him all of me.

That’s why Paul says in Galatians 2:20, “I have been crucified with Christ, and I no longer live…” That’s not a call to offer ourselves in hopes of new standing—it’s a statement of what’s already true.

Surrender isn’t a door to intimacy—it’s the overflow of it.

A Grace-Oriented Appeal

If you’ve been surrendering to earn God's favor, approval, or nearness—pause.

You’re not a beggar outside the gates. You’re His child, seated with Christ in the heavenlies, indwelt by His Spirit, accepted in the Beloved (Eph. 1:6).

You don’t need to surrender to gain God’s heart. You already have it. Now, in view of His mercy, you can offer your whole self—not to earn love, but because you’re already fully loved.

So the next time you pray, “Lord, I surrender all,” maybe add, “because You already gave me all of Yourself.”

That’s the freedom of surrender rooted in grace.

Photo Credit: Image sourced from Unsplash.com